[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Full-disclosure] URI handling woes in Acrobat Reader, Netscape, Miranda, Skype

Glynn Clements ha scritto:
> Modifying individual programs to protect against a shell-injection bug
> in Windows' URI handler is a workaround (mitigation strategy), not a
> fix.

I repeat. Nowhere is said that ShellExecute (the default "run stuff"
function) takes URLs. It takes strings. A desktop shortcut called
"www.google.com" can hijack execution of "www.google.com" (without a
"http://"; prefix), and many other similar issues. If you pass a path to
it, it damn better had to be an absolute path. If you pass an URL, it
damn better had to be normalized. If your application handles documents
that can include URLs, you *must* implement normalization, goddamn it
(stop pasting strings together, fuckers, the sorry state of security is
entirely your goddamn fault! Skype.exe is 22 MB, surely there is room in
there for a normalization routine)

This is an issue of ambiguous strings that could be URLs or could be
not. It does suck that older applications will remain vulnerable until a
fix (if you want to lobby, lobby right. Work that angle), but I still
maintain that, in principle, this is the fault of sloppy third party